Ethical Change Recommended to Increase Donor Organs in USA
Their proposed solution, which is described in an article published in JAMA's "Viewpoint" section, is similar to a policy in Europe, where unexpected deaths provide substantial numbers of transplantable organs. The “uncontrolled donation after circulatory determination of death” (UDCDD) approach considers the deceased candidates for donation even when death is unexpected and occurs outside a hospital, as long as preservation of organs begins after all life-sustaining efforts have been exhausted.
“To encourage donation through UDCDD, we propose an approach that would consider the decision-making capacity of grieving family members,” says NYU Langone's Arthur Caplan, PhD, professor in the Division of Medical Ethics in the Department of Population Health. “Rather than requesting full authorisation for donation of an organ immediately after the death of a loved one outside a hospital setting, a family would be asked only if they would like to preserve the deceased’s organs so that they might consider donation later.”
Current US policy promotes organ recovery from three sources: neurologic deaths, controlled circulatory deaths, and live donors for kidneys and partial liver transplantation. However, Prof. Caplan and co-authors of the JAMA article believe that the policy cannot meet increasing demand for transplants. Currently, more than 124,000 patients in the US are wait-listed for organs, a number that increases yearly despite attrition from 10,500 who die or become too sick for transplantations.
The proposed solution, the authors note, supports the aim of being sensitive to the specific needs of family members at a time of immense grief and overwhelming stress. “A decision to preserve organs is less complex and consequential than the decision to donate,” according to Prof. Caplan. At a later stage, the family would be asked to consider donation.
The importance of ‘decoupling’ pronouncement of death and requests for organ donation is well established, the authors write. In addition, they recommend that language be changed from “uncontrolled donation” to “permission to preserve” after an “unexpected” death.
As co-author Carolyn Plunkett, MA, a PhD candidate at City University of New York and a researcher in the Medical Ethics Division, explains: “With an appropriate ethical framework to obtain permission for preservation immediately following unexpected circulatory determination of death, and with the actual decision to authorise donation made hours thereafter, the pool of potential donors could be greatly expanded while respecting autonomy, choice, and vulnerability.”
Source: NYU Langone Medical Center
Image Credit: Flickr.com
Published on : Tue, 12 May 2015
Intended to establish emergency airway access when endotracheal intubation cannot be performed. Features and benefits Airway access is achieved by using the Seldinger technique via the cricothyroid membrane. The uncuffed airway...
The iLA membrane ventilator is an extrapulmonary ventilation system which is used to remove carbon dioxide. The heart pumps blood through the iLA membrane ventilator as it does through a natural organ. The iLA membrane ventilator “breathes” outside...
Intended for emergency transtracheal catheter ventilation when conventional ventilation by mask or endotracheal tube cannot be performed. Features and benefits The set provides clinicians with a compact solution for quickly establishing...
Stay informed at every point of care In compliance with out-of-hospital patient transport standards such as EN1789, EN13718-1, IEC60601-1-12 and U.S. military standards, N1 is a highly competent solution for various out-of-hospital transport settings...