#RSNA14: “Getting Scans Faster” by Entering Erroneous Information Puts Patients at Risk
The study was conducted at Cork University Hospital (CUH), the second largest hospital in Ireland and a level 1 trauma centre. Although electronic requests are thought to be efficient, legible and traceable and conducive to improved workflow, there was anecdotal evidence of incorrect electronic information at CUH. Radiologists suspected that clinical colleagues were entering erroneous data in order to "get scans faster".
Their study set out to see how common this was by formally assessing and quantifying the problem. They investigated the rate of erroneous biochemical and haematological parameters, as detailed on 250 randomly selected electronic requests - for CT pulmonary angiogram (CTPA) (n=100), CT Thorax (n=70) and abdominopelvic CT (n=80), submitted on the Radiology Information System (RIS) over a 6 month period. The creatinine level, haemoglobin level, CRP and WCC levels supplied for each patient by the referring clinician were compared to the reported levels on the hospital’s biochemical and haematology electronic reporting system, which is not linked to the RIS. In the CTPA subgroup d-dimer levels and pO2 levels were also compared. The level of experience of the referring clinician and the referring department were also recorded.
Overall 45 percent of the total 250 requests contained erroneous information about creatinine, haemoglobin, white cell count and C-reactive protein levels. CTPA requests had a significant number of erroneous D-dimer and pO2 levels; 15 percent reported an abnormal D-dimer result when the actual reported result was normal. A further 25 percent had reported hypoxia when the reported pO2 was normal. Ten percent of all requests contained an incorrect normal creatinine level. Thirty percent of abdominopelvic CT requests detailed a low haemoglobin with iron deficiency anaemia; however, the formal reported results were normal or revealed a normochromic normocyctic anaemia in 75 percent. Elevated CRP and/or WCC were reported in 70 percent of acute abdominopelvic CT requests; 20 percent of the formal results in this subgroup were normal.
Forty-five percent of requests were completed by interns. Ninety percent of incorrect lab results were entered by internal medical physicians, mostly junior residents In addition, a significantly higher incidence of erroneous lab results were supplied by medical physician referrals compared to surgeons.
Noted Twomey, “Clinicians must be aware that providing incorrect clinical information may result in inappropriate prioritisation, protocolling and administration of IV contrast, with an impact on the accuracy of the consequent radiology report and engagement with referrers.
Twomey recommended that ideally all biochemical and haematological results would be double-checked with the lab system. In practice, however, this would be laborious and would affect workflow. Dr. Twomey's team instead recommends the implementation of an electronic ordering system linked directly to patients' laboratory reports and, ideally, the electronic patient chart. “The software exists and is in use, but it is not available in our and many other institutions," Dr. Twomey said. "Budgetary constraints are prevalent throughout radiology; however, these findings would support capital input into this software."
Managing Editor, HealthManagement
Published on : Sun, 7 Dec 2014
The next level in usability ARIETTA 50LE is the compact entry model of the ARIETTA series, inviting easy operation from beginners through experts, taking you to the ‘next level’. This ultrasound platform combines Carefree Workflow, Clear...
Superb Low Dose CT SCENARIA View continues its evolution for doctors, operators and patients, driving you ahead with a superb low dose CT. Hitachi’s Intelli IPV technology with Visual Modeling enables both, significant noise and dose...
Better detection. Clinically superior. Low dose.** What if we could find breast cancers earlier? See lesions more clearly? Reduce the number of unnecessary biopsies? Questions like these inspired Hologic researchers and scientists to develop Hologic...