Breast Screening in Germany - Few Well-Informed
Breast cancer is the most common type of cancer among women. Early diagnosis through MSP can help to lower the mortality rate. Every two years, women aged between 50 and 69 years are invited to attend the regular screening programme. However, because not every screening delivers a clear outcome, mistakes can sometimes lead to false diagnoses, overtreatment or stress. This has spawned controversy over whether the potential disadvantages of screening possibly outweigh the advantages. For this reason, the concept of informed choice comprising knowledge, attitude and intention has gained importance.
"That is why every woman should take care to find out about the risks and the benefits before accepting the invitation to attend mammography screening," according to Junior Professor Dr. Jacob Spallek, who ran the study together with Professor Petra Kolip.
See also: Breast Cancer Routinely Overdiagnosed in Norway
The goal of the research project was to describe which proportion of women in general and which proportion of women with a Turkish migration background decide in favour of or against MSP — and also make an informed choice. Participants were approximately 5,000 women in the Westphalia-Lippe region who were invited to attend an MSP for the first time.
Overall, 27.1 percent of the invited women made an informed choice for or against participating in the MSP. Whereas 28.2 percent of the women with no migration background made an informed choice, this was 21.8 percent among ethnic German immigrants (Spätaussiedlerinnen) and 20.0 percent among women with other countries of origin. The lowest proportion of informed decisions came from women with a Turkish migration background at 5.0 percent
"The proportion of informed choice is generally low in our study, even among women with high educational level," co-author Eva-Maria Berens told HealthManagement.org. She suggested ways to help more women invited for screening make informed choices. "First of all the official information materials will have to be improved substantially. Currently the information materials in Germany are being revised. But secondly, we need measures to improve women's ability to deal with such complex health information and enable them to critically assess information before making a decision," Berens said.
In Australia and the UK, there has been research and action on information provision on risks and benefits of breast screening so women can have sufficient knowledge about screening and make informed decisions. "There is already some research in that area in Germany," Berens noted. "However, these activities are not tailored for migrants or different education levels. So we will need more research on the special information needs of women with deficiencies in informed choice (namely migrants and women of low education level) and as a second step, interventions to especially target these groups."
Claire Pillar, Managing Editor, HealthManagement.org
Source: Bielefeld University; Interview
Image credit: Bielefeld University
Published on : Fri, 13 Nov 2015
The first wireless, handheld breast ultrasound scanner with exceptional image quality Optimized with preset modes for breast, dense breast and interventional procedures that simplify workflow On-demand high-resolution images – 14 MHz, 192 elements, and...
Based on Mindray's new generation ultrasound platform, mQuadro, M9 has raised the industry standards to an all new level. Advanced signal transmission and reception processors provide highly sensitive and accurate echo detection. Innovative transducer...
Powered by the most revolutionary ZONE Sonography® Technology, Resona 7’s new ZST+ platform brings the ultrasound image quality to a higher level by zone acquisition and channel data processing. Resona 7 also provides clinical research with the revolutionary...
Redefining the Vision of Cardiovascular The LISENDO 880 is Hitachi’s premium 2D/4D diagnostic ultrasound solution for cardiologists in any clinical setting. The LISENDO 880 platform is redefining the vision for cardiac ultrasound by providing exceptional...
Digital electrocardiograph / 16-channel / with touchscreen CARDIOVIT AT-170 SCHILLER
Robust design with high-performance
SCHILLER’s new high-end electrocardiograph AT-170 completes the proven AT product range. It offers robust design for the busiest hospitals, as well as a combination of applications that makes it the ideal multi-use workstation for private practices....