Sepsis protocol: variable impact on mortality in Brazil
Public hospitals in emerging countries pose a challenge to quality improvement initiatives in sepsis, as these facilities usually have limited resources and inadequate staff qualification, amongst other limitations. One of the main barriers is the low awareness of sepsis, leading to late recognition with a consequent delay in intervention and increased lethality. A new study shows that quality improvement initiatives reduced sepsis mortality in public Brazilian institutions, although not in all of them. Early recognition seems to be a more relevant factor than compliance with the 6-hour bundle.
Quality improvement initiatives are successful in reducing fatality rates in high-income countries, but there are only a few reports of such initiatives in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). Early recognition and training of hospital staff are associated with a reduction in the severity of illness among patients with sepsis, as well as with lower severity scores and less organ dysfunction at the time of the sepsis diagnosis.
For this research, investigators in Brazil conducted a prospective study of patients with sepsis or septic shock. After collecting data on compliance with the Surviving Sepsis Campaign 6-hour bundles and mortality, researchers initiated a multifaceted quality improvement initiative for patients with sepsis or septic shock in all hospital sectors. The primary outcome was hospital mortality over time. The secondary outcomes were the time to sepsis diagnosis and compliance with the entire 6-hour bundles throughout the intervention.
The study included 3,435 patients from the emergency departments (50.7%), wards (34.1%), and intensive care units (15.2%) of nine institutions. Throughout the intervention, there was an overall reduction in the risk of death, in the proportion of septic shock, and the time to sepsis diagnosis, as well as an improvement in compliance with the 6-hour bundle. Notably the time to sepsis diagnosis, but not the compliance with bundles, was associated with a reduction in the risk of death. However, there was a significant reduction in mortality in only two institutions.
"Although data from resource-limited settings are scarce, mortality reduction is not a consistent or sustained finding," the authors write. "Our findings support this heterogeneity because only two institutions reduced their mortality rates despite the consistent global improvement in other quality indicators. In the successful institutions, there was a greater reduction in the time to sepsis diagnosis, reinforcing the results of our multivariate analysis."
The authors defined successful institutions as those where the mortality rates decreased significantly over time, using a logistic regression model. They analysed differences over time in the secondary outcomes by comparing the successful institutions with the nonsuccessful ones. While the reduction in the time to sepsis diagnosis was greater in the successful institutions, by comparison the nonsuccessful sites had a greater increase in compliance with the 6-hour bundle.
The study has some limitations including that researchers did not assess other information that could explain the differences between institutions, such as the availability of resources, staffing, ICU availability, and other general institutional quality indicators.
"Organisational factors in each of the institutions, such as nurse/patient ratio, physician and resident staffing hours, the presence of multidisciplinary rounds, the use of protocols in the ICU, or the use of checklists, are not described and might have influenced the results," the authors explain.
Source: Critical Care
Published on : Tue, 7 Nov 2017
Intended to establish emergency airway access when endotracheal intubation cannot be performed. Features and benefits Airway access is achieved by using the Seldinger technique via the cricothyroid membrane. The airway catheter is...
Features SV 300 is a state-of-the-art ventilator that’s simple to configure, easy to operate and versatile in use. It equips with extensive ventilation modes that can treats pediatric and adult patients with all acuity levels at ICUs and Intermediate...
Features Mindray BeneVision Central Monitoring System is a powerful and scalable solution providing for continuous, real-time surveillance across networks large and small. The system can display patient information from networked monitors, wireless...
User experience enhanced by leading technologies With state-of-the-art screen technology, BeneVision N-Series patient monitors deliver clear, multi-color, wide-format displays for users to capture and review information at a glance. With...