Increased demand and treacherous road conditions during the winter
months combine to stretch ambulance services in England, which have a
target of reaching 75% of immediately life-threatening (category A)
calls within eight minutes, say the authors.
Studies on the impact of extreme weather conditions on health have tended to focus on associated illness and death, but there has been relatively little research on the impact of weather on NHS infrastructure in the UK, say the authors.
They therefore looked at how the weather affected daily ambulance
call-out and response times in Birmingham, a major conurbation in the
Midlands, over a five year period between 2007 and 2011.
This added up to 1705 days and 794,137 emergency calls, of which
282,978 were category A. And it included several weather extremes: the
floods of July 2007 and the very cold Decembers of 2009 and 2010.
Their analysis revealed a gradual rise in daily ambulance call-outs
from an average of 400 in 2007 to just over 500 in 2011: an increase of
Both call-out and response times were significantly affected by
extremes of weather. Winter was marginally worse for all 36 types of
medical condition included in the analysis.
In December 2010, which was the coldest December on record for more
than a century, with an average temperature of -1°C, the average daily
number of call-outs was 20% higher than in November 2010.
The target ambulance response time fell below 50% three days in a
row. Rather than eight minutes, the average time taken to arrive was 15
Every 1 degree fall in air temperature corresponded to a 1.3% drop in
performance, as call-out volume increased and adverse weather
conditions worsened road travel.
"Cold waves" are likely to have as great an impact on ambulance
call-out and response times as heat waves, say the authors, who warn
that climate change will prompt further temperature extremes.
"The impact of climate change will primarily be seen through more
incidents of extreme cold and hot weather, and therefore it will be
useful to examine adaption measures such as the use of winter tyres and
more flexibility in the number of ambulances available for operation
during extreme weather episodes," they write.
"Furthermore, with colder winters and hotter summers, the challenges
associated with achieving summer/winter response times, particularly due
to increases in call volume, are likely to increase," they warn.