Effect Sizes in Ongoing Critical Care Trials
Estimates of prior probability are important to the proper interpretation of a randomised controlled trial's results. For some of the largest ongoing critical care trials, many clinicians regard prior probabilities as low and consider that plausible effects on absolute mortality for study treatments being investigated are less than 5%, according to a systematic review published in the journal Critical Care.
Mortality measured at a particular time point (landmark mortality) is often regarded as the gold standard outcome for randomised controlled trials in critical care medicine. However, the utility of trials in generating evidence for interventions to increase survival in intensive care unit (ICU) patients has been disputed.
An important limitation of many critical care trials is that they hypothesise large, and potentially implausible, reductions in mortality. This is a major problem in trial design for two reasons. First, it makes a type II error (false-negative) more likely. Second, the less plausible a postulated mortality reduction is, the more likely it is that a statistically significant mortality difference will represent a type I error (false-positive).
Interpretation of trial results could be improved by systematic assessment of the plausibility of trial hypotheses; however, such assessment has not been attempted in the field of critical care medicine. In this study, researchers sought to determine clinicians’ views about prior probabilities and plausible effect sizes for ongoing critical care trials where the primary outcome is landmark mortality.
The research team conducted a systematic review of clinical trial registries in September 2015 to identify relevant clinical trials, followed by a clinician survey to obtain opinions about 10 large trials. Clinicians were asked to estimate the probability that each trial would demonstrate a mortality effect equal to or larger than that used in its sample size calculations.
Estimates provided by individual clinicians varied from 0% to 100% for most trials, with a median estimate of 15%. The median largest absolute mortality reduction considered plausible was 4.5%, compared with a median absolute mortality reduction used in sample size calculations of 5%.
The authors state, "our finding that effect sizes postulated by investigators often appear to be larger than the median effect sizes considered plausible by clinicians is consistent with previous literature suggesting that effect sizes used to inform sample size calculations are often inflated."
Also, they note that further work is needed to determine whether pooled estimates obtained by surveying clinicians are replicable and accurate or whether other methods of estimating prior probability are preferred.
Source: Critical Care
Image Credit: Pixabay
Published on : Tue, 13 Jun 2017
Intended to establish emergency airway access when endotracheal intubation cannot be performed. Features and benefits Supplied in a slip-peel pouch for easy transportation. The dilators are preinserted into the airway catheters for...
Especially developed for long-term lung support. This patient kit includes a powerful membrane lung, the DP3 pump head, safe integrated pressure sensors (IPS) and a CRRT connector. One vascular access offers the possibility to combine the therapies for...
Intended for uncomplicated, atraumatic endotracheal tube exchange. Features and benefits The blunt tip of the catheter is atraumatic to internal structures. The lumen and distal sideports are designed to deliver oxygen. The centimetre...
Single Lumen Dual Port Nasogastric Feeding and Drainage Tube Designed for the ICU Compat Dualport is designed to help simplify gastric drainage and administration of nutrition, fluids and medications by the use of one single tube for both operations....
Intended for staged extubation and subsequent reintubation. Features and benefits The soft, blunt tip is designed to be atraumatic to internal structures. The distal sideports ensure sufficient airflow and prevent whipping during use...